"Duffy? Fucking Duffy?!"
But I'm getting ahead of myself.
Earlier this week the Lass & I went to a preview screening of The Boat That Rocked, a film ostensibly about the UK pirate radio of the Sixties, complete with a solid cast and Richard Curtis writing & directing. I've always had a soft spot for Curtis, partly for the brilliant Blackadder, mainly for the wonderful adaptation of the Odyssey that he did with Tony Robinson for BBC Children (I've still got the two books they did and they remain a thrilling hoot to read). I wasn't expecting a classic film, but some easy-going fun with good laughs and a decent soundtrack seemed certain. Well, I was right about the music...
- Pirate radio plays rock & pop music!
- All women want to sleep with the DJs, except lesbians (and even they don't mind a grope)!
- The entire nation listens to this one station and keeps dancing, dancing, dancing, every hour of every day!
- Everyone, that is, except for the Government, with their suits and classical music, who just want to stop everyone having fun, because apparently fun is dangerous and anti-establishment! Booooooo!
And that's pretty much it. It's so insultingly simplistic, I kept waiting for things to take a turn, an "ah-ha!" to give it all some depth, relevance, a reflection of reality. Never happens - as social history goes, Austin Powers was more realistic and nuanced than this nonsense, while the depiction of women is on a par with the Sun and Loaded - they're there to worship the men, get their tits out and dance giddily, nothing more, and the film is perfectly happy with that. Fucks sake, the Carry On films were progressive compared to this. No wonder the only good quotes on the posters came from red-top tabloids.
So, it's not trying to show how things really were, more some clichéd, idealised rose-and-dope-tinted version of the Sixties. Is that so bad? Well, it is if the start and end of the film purport to place the story in the context of our social history, especially when the real story of Radio Caroline is far more interesting & relevant than what's shown here.
But no, instead you get some remarkably flat characters which really don't deserve the actors they get - Philip Seymour Hoffman is excellent, doing the best he can with a shitty script, and Bill Nighy is clearly having a ball. Indeed, it looks like the sort of film where people had a great time making it, only that doesn't carry through to the finished product. What little comedy there is barely survives the first hour, after which even a genuine humoured smile is hard to come by. There's dialogue in this film that you'd take to be a weak parody of Curtis' earlier work, if it hadn't been written by the man himself. See the dreadful Hugh-Grantesque gosh-I'm-so-terribly-awkward-but-you're-awfully-lovely speech that the frankly useless central character gives, or the bogglingly dumb move of giving not one but two of the establishment figures a 'naughty' name (Twatt and Clitt, for what it's worth. Seriously.) that barely raises a smile the first time and just grates after the second. The storytelling is feeble, the first half basically consisting of a bunch of scenes that never seem to connect to each other, while the second half is sodding woeful. I could've just about forgiven the flaws of the first hour, but the second is truly awful (and way too long to boot - this film is over two hours long and feels it) as the boat springs a leak and it turns into fucking Titanic of all things. And where earlier Curtis-scripted films would bring things together nicely, if cheesily, at the end, TBTR fails utterly. It tries to generate a drama, a heartlift that it hasn't lifted a finger to earn, instead generating nothing but rolling eyes and utter exasperation, tempered only with relief that finally, thankfully it's all over.
Honestly, there's hardly anything good to be said about the whole 2 hours 10 minutes. The soundtrack is certainly good, but with zero surprises you could hear the contents on Radio 2 or any mainstream classic gold station. Hell, chances are you've got most of the songs already, so save your time, save your money, stay at home and put some of those classic songs on yourself. You'll get so much more out of them pure than filtered and bellowed over by the film. And for a real taste of the difference pop music made to so many lives, read something like The Peel Sessions. Evocative, thrilling, it goes some way to capturing the sense of history, excitement and change that this music represented, something TBTR purports to do, yet fails in the weakest, dullest, squarest way.
And the above outburst? At the very end, following a knuckle-gnawingly embarrassing chorus of the cast yelling "rock and roll!!!" (you'll pray for punks, mods & rockers to turn up on gunboats and blow everyone out of the water) there's some godawful text attempting to place the film in the context of modern musical history, basically saying "thanks to all that, there's hundreds of radio stations today playing rock & pop" (with sod all mention of how the real pirate DJs led the charge on Radio 1, presumably as that'd sound too establishmenty) followed by a montage of album covers which are supposed to symbolise the very best of the last 40+ years of music but basically looks like an old iPod commercial showing off Curtis' CD collection. The very fact that the bland warblings of Duffy are one such highlight should tell you everything about the mentality of this film that makes rock'n'roll look as flacid, inoffensive and irrelevant as the establishment it seeks to mock. Rarely has there been a film so thoroughly slappable. This ain't rock'n'roll... this is shit.






Oh well, here we goes again. Only a few months after we
Anyhoo, very chuffed to notice Friday afternoon that a 


Recent Comments